ALL TEAMS
| TEAM | OVERALL |
|---|---|
 Navy | 4–2 |
 Penn State | 3–2 |
 Army | 2–1 |
 Massachusetts | 2–5 |
 Rutgers | 2–4 |
 Michigan | 0–2 |
 Virginia | 0–0–1 |
 Syracuse | 0–1 |
Conference membership isn’t recorded for 1891, so every team is listed together with its overall record.
| TEAM | OVERALL |
|---|---|
| Navy | 4–2 |
| Penn State | 3–2 |
| Army | 2–1 |
| Massachusetts | 2–5 |
| Rutgers | 2–4 |
| Michigan | 0–2 |
| Virginia | 0–0–1 |
| Syracuse | 0–1 |
Conference membership isn’t recorded for 1891, so every team is listed together with its overall record.