| 1991 | Sep 21, 1991 | William & Mary 26, Navy 21 | – |
| 1987 | Sep 12, 1987 | William & Mary 27, Navy 12 | – |
| 1982 | Oct 16, 1982 | Navy 39, William & Mary 3 | – |
| 1981 | Oct 24, 1981 | Navy 27, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1980 | Sep 27, 1980 | Navy 45, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1979 | Oct 13, 1979 | Navy 24, William & Mary 7 | – |
| 1978 | Oct 21, 1978 | Navy 9, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1977 | Oct 22, 1977 | Navy 42, William & Mary 17 | – |
| 1976 | Oct 16, 1976 | William & Mary 21, Navy 13 | – |
| 1972 | Sep 16, 1972 | Navy 13, William & Mary 9 | – |
| 1967 | Oct 21, 1967 | William & Mary 27, Navy 16 | – |
| 1966 | Oct 22, 1966 | Navy 21, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1965 | Oct 9, 1965 | Navy 42, William & Mary 14 | – |
| 1964 | Sep 26, 1964 | Navy 35, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1963 | Sep 28, 1963 | Navy 28, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1962 | Sep 29, 1962 | Navy 20, William & Mary 16 | – |
| 1961 | Sep 30, 1961 | Navy 44, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1959 | Sep 26, 1959 | Navy 29, William & Mary 2 | – |
| 1958 | Sep 27, 1958 | Navy 14, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1957 | Sep 28, 1957 | Navy 33, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1956 | Sep 29, 1956 | Navy 39, William & Mary 14 | – |
| 1955 | Sep 24, 1955 | Navy 7, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1954 | Sep 25, 1954 | Navy 27, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1953 | Sep 26, 1953 | William & Mary 6, Navy 6 | – |
| 1952 | Oct 11, 1952 | Navy 14, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1942 | Sep 26, 1942 | William & Mary 3, Navy 0 | – |
| 1941 | Sep 27, 1941 | Navy 34, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1940 | Sep 28, 1940 | Navy 19, William & Mary 7 | – |
| 1939 | Sep 30, 1939 | Navy 31, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1938 | Sep 24, 1938 | Navy 26, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1937 | Sep 25, 1937 | Navy 45, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1936 | Sep 26, 1936 | Navy 18, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1935 | Sep 28, 1935 | Navy 30, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1934 | Sep 29, 1934 | Navy 20, William & Mary 7 | – |
| 1933 | Sep 30, 1933 | Navy 12, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1932 | Oct 1, 1932 | William & Mary 6, Navy 0 | – |
| 1931 | Oct 3, 1931 | Navy 13, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1930 | Oct 4, 1930 | Navy 19, William & Mary 6 | – |
| 1929 | Oct 5, 1929 | Navy 15, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1925 | Oct 3, 1925 | Navy 25, William & Mary 0 | – |
| 1924 | Oct 4, 1924 | Navy 14, William & Mary 7 | – |
| 1923 | Sep 29, 1923 | Navy 39, William & Mary 10 | – |
