| 2025 | Nov 8, 2025 | Northern Arizona 49, Northern Colorado 10 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2024 | Nov 16, 2024 | Northern Arizona 44, Northern Colorado 3 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2023 | Nov 11, 2023 | Northern Arizona 28, Northern Colorado 7 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2022 | Nov 12, 2022 | Northern Colorado 21, Northern Arizona 20 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2021 | Sep 25, 2021 | Northern Colorado 17, Northern Arizona 10 (OT) (OT) | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2019 | Oct 5, 2019 | Northern Arizona 41, Northern Colorado 23 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2018 | Oct 20, 2018 | Northern Colorado 42, Northern Arizona 14 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2017 | Sep 30, 2017 | Northern Arizona 48, Northern Colorado 20 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2016 | Oct 1, 2016 | Northern Colorado 21, Northern Arizona 18 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2015 | Oct 31, 2015 | Northern Arizona 63, Northern Colorado 21 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2014 | Oct 4, 2014 | Northern Colorado 24, Northern Arizona 17 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2013 | Nov 16, 2013 | Northern Arizona 24, Northern Colorado 7 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2011 | Nov 5, 2011 | Northern Arizona 34, Northern Colorado 14 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2010 | Nov 6, 2010 | Northern Arizona 21, Northern Colorado 14 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2009 | Oct 3, 2009 | Northern Arizona 35, Northern Colorado 27 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2008 | Sep 27, 2008 | Northern Arizona 25, Northern Colorado 22 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |
| 2007 | Sep 22, 2007 | Northern Arizona 34, Northern Colorado 14 | Walkup Skydome · Flagstaff, AZ |
| 2006 | Nov 18, 2006 | Northern Arizona 54, Northern Colorado 3 | Nottingham Field · Greeley, CO |