| 2011 | Oct 29, 2011 | West Virginia 41, Rutgers 31 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2010 | Dec 4, 2010 | West Virginia 35, Rutgers 14 | Milan Puskar Stadium · Morgantown, WV |
| 2009 | Dec 5, 2009 | West Virginia 24, Rutgers 21 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2008 | Oct 4, 2008 | West Virginia 24, Rutgers 17 | Milan Puskar Stadium · Morgantown, WV |
| 2007 | Oct 27, 2007 | West Virginia 31, Rutgers 3 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2006 | Dec 2, 2006 | West Virginia 41, Rutgers 39 (OT) (OT) | Milan Puskar Stadium · Morgantown, WV |
| 2005 | Oct 8, 2005 | West Virginia 27, Rutgers 14 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2004 | Oct 30, 2004 | West Virginia 35, Rutgers 30 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2003 | Oct 11, 2003 | West Virginia 34, Rutgers 19 | Milan Puskar Stadium · Morgantown, WV |
| 2002 | Oct 12, 2002 | West Virginia 40, Rutgers 0 | High Point Solutions Stadium · Piscataway, NJ |
| 2001 | Nov 3, 2001 | West Virginia 80, Rutgers 7 | Milan Puskar Stadium · Morgantown, WV |
| 2000 | Nov 11, 2000 | West Virginia 31, Rutgers 24 | – |
| 1999 | Oct 16, 1999 | West Virginia 62, Rutgers 16 | – |
| 1998 | Nov 14, 1998 | West Virginia 28, Rutgers 14 | – |
| 1997 | Oct 4, 1997 | West Virginia 48, Rutgers 0 | – |
| 1996 | Nov 9, 1996 | West Virginia 55, Rutgers 14 | – |
| 1995 | Nov 4, 1995 | West Virginia 59, Rutgers 26 | – |
| 1994 | Sep 10, 1994 | Rutgers 17, West Virginia 12 | – |
| 1993 | Nov 6, 1993 | West Virginia 58, Rutgers 22 | – |
| 1992 | Nov 14, 1992 | Rutgers 13, West Virginia 9 | – |
| 1991 | Nov 2, 1991 | West Virginia 28, Rutgers 3 | – |
| 1990 | Nov 10, 1990 | West Virginia 28, Rutgers 3 | – |
| 1989 | Nov 11, 1989 | West Virginia 21, Rutgers 20 | – |
| 1988 | Nov 12, 1988 | West Virginia 35, Rutgers 25 | – |
| 1987 | Nov 14, 1987 | West Virginia 37, Rutgers 13 | – |
| 1986 | Nov 8, 1986 | West Virginia 24, Rutgers 17 | – |
| 1985 | Nov 9, 1985 | West Virginia 27, Rutgers 0 | – |
| 1984 | Nov 10, 1984 | Rutgers 23, West Virginia 19 | – |
| 1983 | Nov 12, 1983 | West Virginia 35, Rutgers 7 | – |
| 1982 | Nov 11, 1982 | West Virginia 44, Rutgers 17 | – |
| 1981 | Nov 14, 1981 | West Virginia 20, Rutgers 3 | – |
| 1980 | Nov 15, 1980 | West Virginia 24, Rutgers 15 | – |
| 1923 | Nov 6, 1923 | West Virginia 27, Rutgers 7 | – |
| 1922 | Oct 28, 1922 | West Virginia 28, Rutgers 0 | – |
| 1921 | Nov 19, 1921 | Rutgers 17, West Virginia 7 | – |
| 1920 | Nov 13, 1920 | West Virginia 17, Rutgers 0 | – |
| 1919 | Nov 15, 1919 | West Virginia 30, Rutgers 7 | – |
| 1917 | Nov 3, 1917 | West Virginia 7, Rutgers 7 | – |
| 1916 | Nov 11, 1916 | West Virginia 0, Rutgers 0 | – |