| 2021 | Nov 6, 2021 | Utah State 35, New Mexico State 13 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2018 | Sep 8, 2018 | Utah State 60, New Mexico State 13 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2017 | Dec 29, 2017 | New Mexico State 26, Utah State 20 (OT) (OT) | Arizona Stadium · Tucson, AZ · Neutral |
| 2012 | Oct 20, 2012 | Utah State 41, New Mexico State 7 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2011 | Dec 3, 2011 | Utah State 24, New Mexico State 21 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2010 | Nov 6, 2010 | Utah State 27, New Mexico State 22 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2009 | Oct 10, 2009 | New Mexico State 20, Utah State 17 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2008 | Nov 29, 2008 | Utah State 47, New Mexico State 2 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2007 | Nov 17, 2007 | Utah State 35, New Mexico State 17 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2006 | Nov 25, 2006 | New Mexico State 42, Utah State 20 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2005 | Nov 26, 2005 | Utah State 24, New Mexico State 21 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2004 | Nov 20, 2004 | Utah State 34, New Mexico State 25 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2003 | Nov 6, 2003 | New Mexico State 26, Utah State 21 | Aggie Memorial Stadium · Las Cruces, NM |
| 2002 | Nov 9, 2002 | Utah State 32, New Mexico State 30 | Maverik Stadium · Logan, UT |
| 2000 | Nov 4, 2000 | Utah State 44, New Mexico State 37 | – |
| 1999 | Nov 6, 1999 | New Mexico State 14, Utah State 6 | – |
| 1998 | Oct 31, 1998 | Utah State 29, New Mexico State 26 | – |
| 1997 | Oct 18, 1997 | Utah State 38, New Mexico State 7 | – |
| 1996 | Oct 12, 1996 | Utah State 53, New Mexico State 21 | – |
| 1995 | Oct 21, 1995 | Utah State 27, New Mexico State 14 | – |
| 1994 | Nov 19, 1994 | Utah State 47, New Mexico State 20 | – |
| 1993 | Nov 20, 1993 | Utah State 20, New Mexico State 17 | – |
| 1992 | Sep 26, 1992 | Utah State 48, New Mexico State 21 | – |
| 1991 | Nov 23, 1991 | Utah State 46, New Mexico State 21 | – |
| 1990 | Nov 3, 1990 | Utah State 55, New Mexico State 10 | – |
| 1989 | Oct 21, 1989 | Utah State 28, New Mexico State 13 | – |
| 1988 | Sep 24, 1988 | Utah State 32, New Mexico State 20 | – |
| 1987 | Nov 7, 1987 | Utah State 25, New Mexico State 6 | – |
| 1986 | Oct 4, 1986 | Utah State 42, New Mexico State 9 | – |
| 1985 | Nov 23, 1985 | Utah State 40, New Mexico State 23 | – |
| 1973 | Nov 10, 1973 | Utah State 40, New Mexico State 12 | – |
| 1972 | Sep 9, 1972 | Utah State 48, New Mexico State 14 | – |
| 1971 | Sep 18, 1971 | Utah State 34, New Mexico State 0 | – |
| 1970 | Nov 28, 1970 | Utah State 45, New Mexico State 21 | – |
| 1968 | Sep 14, 1968 | Utah State 28, New Mexico State 12 | – |
| 1967 | Sep 30, 1967 | New Mexico State 10, Utah State 9 | – |
| 1966 | Oct 1, 1966 | New Mexico State 23, Utah State 7 | – |
| 1964 | Sep 26, 1964 | Utah State 76, New Mexico State 0 | – |
| 1963 | Nov 16, 1963 | Utah State 7, New Mexico State 6 | – |
| 1960 | Dec 31, 1960 | New Mexico State 20, Utah State 13 | – |